The Myths About S Corporations—and Why They’re Commonly Misused

NICHOLAS HAMMERNIK • September 4, 2025


For many business owners, choosing the right entity type is one of the most important financial decisions they’ll ever make. Among the most

popular choices is the S Corporation (S Corp). While this structure can offer significant tax advantages in the right circumstances, it’s also one of the most misunderstood and misused business entities.


Below, we’ll break down the most common myths about S Corporations—and explain why so many owners run into trouble when they don’t fully understand how the rules really work.


Myth #1: An S Corporation Is a Type of Business Entity


The Truth: An S Corporation isn’t actually a type of business entity—it’s a tax election.


You don’t “form” an S Corporation; you first create a corporation or limited liability company (LLC) and then elect S Corporation tax treatment with the IRS. Many owners assume the S Corp is a completely separate structure, but it’s simply a way of telling the IRS how you want your profits, losses, and distributions to be taxed.


Myth #2: S Corporations Eliminate Self-Employment Taxes


The Truth: S Corps can reduce self-employment taxes, but they don’t make them disappear.


One of the biggest selling points people hear is that S Corps “save you thousands in taxes” because you avoid self-employment tax. But here’s the catch: the IRS requires that S Corporation owners pay themselves a reasonable salary. That salary is subject to payroll taxes (Social Security and Medicare), just like any other employee. Only the profit distributions above that salary are exempt from self-employment tax.

If you pay yourself too little, the IRS can reclassify your distributions as wages and hit you with penalties.


Myth #3: Everyone Should Be an S Corporation


The Truth: S Corps are not always the best fit.


For small businesses just starting out or those with modest profits, the additional payroll filings, state requirements, and accounting complexities may outweigh the tax benefits. In some cases, an LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship—or even a C Corporation—may be the better option depending on your long-term goals, reinvestment strategy, or desire for outside investors.


Myth #4: S Corporations Save You Money Automatically


The Truth: S Corps only save money if they’re structured and maintained correctly.



Yes, you can save on self-employment taxes by splitting income between salary and distributions. But if your books aren’t clean, payroll isn’t processed properly, or distributions are handled incorrectly, those “savings” can evaporate into penalties, audits, and unnecessary stress.


Myth #5: You Don’t Need Help Managing an S Corporation


The Truth: S Corps require ongoing compliance and proactive tax planning.


An S Corp isn’t a “set it and forget it” election. Owners must manage reasonable compensation, payroll tax filings, shareholder basis tracking, state-level requirements, and annual elections. Without guidance from a knowledgeable accountant and tax planner, many owners misuse the structure—leaving money on the table or creating IRS red flags.


Why S Corporations Are Commonly Misused


  1. Misinformation from peers or online sources – Many owners hear about S Corps from friends, family, or internet forums without understanding the full picture. "S Corporation" has become an internet buzz word that influences many business owners to assume they should be structured as one, without analyzing their personal situation.
  2. DIY entity setup – Filing the election without professional guidance often leads to mistakes in payroll, distributions, and recordkeeping.
  3. Lack of proactive planning – Owners make the election but never revisit whether it’s still the right choice as the business grows.
  4. Focus on short-term tax savings – Without considering long-term goals like retirement planning, exit strategy, or bringing on partners, the S Corp can create limitations.


How Hammernik & Associates Helps


At Hammernik & Associates, we know entity choice is not a “one-time decision.” Business goals, income levels, and tax laws change over time—which is why we analyze entity optimization for our clients on an annual basis.


Our team reviews whether your current structure—S Corporation or otherwise—is still the best fit to minimize taxes, reduce risk, and support your long-term strategy. Sometimes, that means staying the course. Other times, it means adjusting salary levels, refining payroll, or even considering a different entity election.


This proactive review helps our clients avoid the common pitfalls of S Corps while ensuring they’re always taking advantage of the best structure for their situation.


The Bottom Line


S Corporations can be a powerful tax-saving tool—but only when used in the right situation and managed correctly. Too often, business owners are sold on the myth of “automatic tax savings” without being told about the responsibilities and pitfalls.


If you’re considering an S Corporation election—or if you already have one and aren’t sure if you’re using it correctly—it’s wise to sit down with a tax advisor who can help you evaluate whether this structure truly fits your business goals.

See More Blog Posts

By Brad Tobin November 18, 2025
Most business owners think their Accountant is “handling their taxes.” But here’s the truth; there’s a massive difference between tax preparation and tax planning , and most accountants only do one of them. 1. Tax Preparation: The History Report Tax preparation is what happens after the year is over. Your CPA gathers your numbers, plugs them into software, and files your returns with the IRS. It’s about compliance by making sure everything is accurate and filed on time. It’s not about strategy; once December 31st has passed, there’s very little that can be done to lower your tax bill. Think of it as your financial “history report.” It’s a look back at what already happened. 2. Tax Planning: The Playbook Tax planning is proactive. It’s about designing your financial life to pay less tax before the year ends. It focuses on strategy; entity structure, retirement contributions, income shifting, real estate strategies, depreciation planning, credits, and deductions that fit your situation. It’s done throughout the year , not just in March or April. It creates real savings , not just “clean paperwork.” Tax planning turns your CPA into a coach, someone who helps you make decisions today that reduce what you owe tomorrow. 3. The Key Question to Ask If you only hear from your CPA at tax time, you’re getting tax prep. If you’re meeting throughout the year, reviewing financials, projecting income, and discussing ways to save, that’s tax planning. Ask your CPA: “What are we doing this year to reduce next year’s taxes?” If they don’t have an answer, it’s time to find someone who does. 4. Why It Matters The difference can be tens of thousands of dollars. Tax prep is a cost. Tax planning is an investment, and it usually pays for itself many times over.
By Brad Tobin October 28, 2025
If you own rental property or are thinking about investing in real estate, one of the biggest decisions you’ll make is whether to operate a short-term rental (STR) like an Airbnb or VRBO, or a long-term rental (LTR) with traditional tenants. While both can generate solid cash flow, the tax differences between short-term and long-term rentals can have a major impact on your bottom line, and the IRS treats them very differently. 1. Short-Term Rentals Are Often Treated Like a Business If your average guest stay is seven days or less, the IRS generally doesn’t treat it as a “rental activity.” Instead, it’s often classified as an active trade or business, similar to running a small hospitality operation. Tax implications of short-term rentals: You may owe self-employment tax if you provide substantial guest services (like cleaning during the stay, meals, or concierge-type help). You might qualify for the Qualified Business Income (QBI) deduction, which can allow up to 20% of your profit to be tax-free. Bonus depreciation and Section 179 expensing may apply to furnishings, décor, and equipment. Losses can be used to offset other active income (business or W-2).  In short, short-term rentals can open the door to more tax deductions, but they also come with more complexity and recordkeeping requirements. 2. Long-Term Rentals Are Usually Passive Income For long-term rentals, where tenants sign leases for months or years, the IRS classifies the activity as passive income. Tax implications of long-term rentals: No self-employment tax applies to rental income. You can claim depreciation deductions to offset income and reduce taxes. You may still qualify for the QBI deduction if the rental activity rises to the level of a trade or business. However, losses from long-term rentals are usually passive losses, which can only offset other passive income unless you qualify as a real estate professional. 3. Faster Write-Offs Through Cost Segregation Both short-term and long-term rental owners can use cost segregation studies to accelerate depreciation. By identifying assets such as furniture, flooring, and appliances that can be depreciated over 5 or 7 years, investors can front-load deductions and reduce taxable income in the early years of ownership, a popular Airbnb tax strategy for maximizing cash flow. 4. Choosing the Right Rental Strategy for Tax Savings Both short-term and long-term rentals offer powerful tax benefits but which is best depends on your goals: Choose short-term rentals if you want flexibility, higher income potential, and more deduction opportunities. Choose long-term rentals if you prefer stability, predictable cash flow, and less day-to-day involvement. Before deciding, talk with a CPA who specializes in real estate taxation. The right setup can help you maximize deductions, reduce your tax liability, and avoid costly mistakes. Short-term and long-term rentals both build wealth, but the tax rules are not one-size-fits-all. Understanding how the IRS classifies your rental activity is key to keeping more of what you earn. If you’re not sure which approach offers the best tax advantage, get professional advice before you buy or convert a property. A well-structured strategy could save you thousands each year.
By NICHOLAS HAMMERNIK October 8, 2025
Unlock the Strategic Path to Tax Savings
By Brad Tobin October 1, 2025
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act has reshaped tax law in ways that directly affect real estate investors. While many changes apply broadly to business owners, real estate stands out as one of the biggest winners, with some important caveats. Here’s what you need to know: 1. 100% Bonus Depreciation is Permanent One of the most valuable tools for real estate investors has been bonus depreciation, allowing immediate write-offs of certain improvements and property components. The new bill makes 100% bonus depreciation permanent. What this means: Cost segregation studies remain a powerful way to accelerate deductions. Investors purchasing or improving property over the next few years can still capture large up-front tax benefits. 2. 1031 Exchanges Fully Preserved There was speculation that like-kind exchanges (1031s) might be curtailed or eliminated. The new law instead fully preserves 1031 exchanges for real estate. What this means: Investors can continue deferring capital gains taxes by rolling proceeds from one property into another. Combined with extended bonus depreciation, this creates opportunities for “swap ‘til you drop” strategies, exchanging property while deducting improvements and eventually receiving a step-up in basis at death. 3. Opportunity Zone Changes Opportunity Zones (OZs), designed to incentivize investment in designated low-income areas, saw important updates under the new law. What changed: The program sees a new 5 year rolling deferral period starting on January 1, 2027, giving investors more time to deploy capital and meet compliance deadlines with basis step ups. What this means: Investors sitting on capital gains still have a chance to defer and potentially reduce those taxes by investing in Qualified Opportunity Funds in 2027. Longer timelines mean more flexibility in planning, but reporting compliance will become more important. 4. Energy-Efficient Provisions Narrowed Under prior law, energy-related credits and deductions had expanded significantly. The new bill rolls some of these back, especially for residential projects, while still preserving limited opportunities for commercial property. What changed: Section 179D (commercial building energy-efficiency deduction) & 45L (new energy efficient home credit) is preserved, but only through June 30, 2026 for projects that begin construction before then. After that, it phases out. Many residential energy credits (solar, HVAC, insulation) are being eliminated or sunset after 2025. Commercial Battery Storage Credit is still available through 2032 and will start to phase out in 2033 and 2034. What this means: Commercial property owners considering efficiency upgrades should act soon there is a clear window of opportunity before these provisions disappear. Residential investors should not rely on tax credits for green improvements going forward. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act creates new opportunities but also deadlines for real estate investors. Extended bonus depreciation and preserved 1031 exchanges keep powerful tax strategies on the table. Opportunity Zones have been given new life, while energy-efficient incentives are on the clock. The key takeaway: timing matters more than ever. Planning acquisitions, improvements, and sales with these changes in mind can mean the difference between maximizing tax savings or missing out. If you’re a real estate investor and want to understand how these provisions apply to your portfolio, let’s connect to review your specific situation.
By Brad Tobin September 23, 2025
In July 2025, Congress passed and the President signed into law the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), bringing major changes to the U.S. tax code that significantly impact businesses, investors, pass-through entities, and estate planning. Many provisions build on the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA). Some are permanent, others temporary, and all require careful planning to maximize opportunities and avoid pitfalls. If you are a business owner, investor, or considering succession or estate planning, these changes could affect you directly. Key Business & Investment Tax Changes QBI Deduction Made Permanent ● 20% deduction for pass-through entity income (LLCs, S-corps, partnerships, sole proprietorships) is now permanent. ● Income thresholds for specified service trades or businesses (SSTBs) increased for 2025 ($394,600 for joint filers and $197,300 for other taxpayers). ● Starting in 2026, phase-in ranges expand: $150k for joint filers and $75k for others. ● Taxpayers with at least $1,000 in QBI may claim a minimum $400 QBI deduction. 100% Bonus Depreciation Permanently Extended ● Businesses can fully deduct qualifying property (equipment, vehicles, and certain buildings) placed in service after Jan 19, 2025. ● Manufacturing buildings qualify if placed in service before Jan 1, 2031. Qualified Opportunity Zones (QOZs) ● Program is now permanent, with new 10-year designations beginning Jan 1, 2027. Estate, Gift, and Succession Planning ● Lifetime estate and gift tax exemption increased to ~$15 million per person (indexed for inflation beginning in 2026). ● Adjustments to Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) for shares issued after July 4, 2025. Tip Credit Expansion ● FICA tip credit extended to beauty service businesses. Other Key Provisions ● Restored Research and Development expensing (Section 174). ● Interest deduction changes (ATI excludes depreciation, amortization, or depletion). ● Higher Section 179 deduction and phase-out thresholds. ● Expanded Low Income Housing Tax Credit allocations. ● Clean Energy Tax Credit changes: Section 45L and 179D repealed after June 30, 2026. Considerations & Challenges ● Some provisions are temporary (e.g., certain deductions and caps), so timing is critical. ● Income phaseouts may limit benefits for high-income pass-through owners. ● Increased compliance complexity (e.g., amended returns, documentation) will be important. ● Real estate ownership structures and financing choices may need reevaluation in light of new depreciation and interest rules. Planning Opportunities for Businesses & Investors Accelerate Capital Expenditures Investing in equipment, vehicles, or eligible buildings now can provide immediate tax benefits through 100% bonus depreciation. Optimize Business Structure for QBI Assess ownership, entity type, and income levels to maximize the 20% deduction. Service businesses might gain advantages by restructuring to distinguish between qualifying and non-qualifying activities. Estate & Succession Planning Take advantage of the higher exemption to transfer assets via gifts or trusts while the thresholds are still beneficial. Consider Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) opportunities if you are investing in or selling small business shares. Leverage Tax Credits & Incentives Investigate possibilities in affordable housing and Qualified Opportunity Zones, but ensure compliance with updated documentation requirements. Cost Segregation for Real Estate Think about conducting cost segregation studies to enhance depreciation benefits on properties. Model Income Scenarios Create multi-year projections to optimize the timing of income, deductions, and asset acquisitions to avoid crossing phaseout thresholds. What’s Next? The One Big Beautiful Bill Act transforms the tax environment for businesses and investors alike. Featuring permanent QBI deductions, reinstated R&D expensing, and bonus depreciation, it unlocks extraordinary chances to minimize taxable income. Additionally, enhanced estate and gift exemptions offer robust strategies for effective succession planning. However, these advantages won’t maximize themselves. Considerations such as timing, entity structure, and integrated planning are crucial — as every choice can significantly alter your tax responsibilities. To understand how these developments affect your unique circumstances, reach out to us at Hammernik & Associates. Together, let’s devise a strategy that strategically positions your business for success in 2025 and beyond.
By NICHOLAS HAMMERNIK September 17, 2025
Thinking about selling your business? Learn when and how to plan your exit, maximize value, minimize taxes, and prepare for a smooth transition.
By NICHOLAS HAMMERNIK August 28, 2025
Discover the difference between forward-looking and backward-looking accounting—and why combining both helps business owners stay compliant and competitive.
By NICHOLAS HAMMERNIK August 20, 2025
Learn what a Virtual Family Office is and how it provides tax, wealth, and business planning strategies once reserved for the ultra-wealthy.
By nicholas December 24, 2020
The “rescue package” has arrived. The COVID Relief bill is a whopping 5,593 pages long. I know you don’t want to sit and read through that novel, so I am here to summarize, in plain English, how this bill is going to effect your taxes. Have you ever been on a roller coaster before? A… The post The COVID Relief Bill Summarized appeared first on Talking Tax to Milwaukee.
By nicholas December 4, 2020
This past week, I finally dove into a project that I has been brewing in my mind for a few years. I published my first podcast episode today. Is it any good? I’m not quite sure. To be honest, I’m not too happy with how it turned out. However, I accomplished part of my goal.… The post The Tax Slang Movement appeared first on Talking Tax to Milwaukee.